The Welsh Liberal Democrats have criticised the Welsh Labour Government's flagship Jobs Growth Wales (JGW) scheme after the Government's own interim report identified a number of weaknesses with the scheme.
The report, released today, found that 73% of those on JGW placements would have found work without the Government scheme. It also notes significant failings to target those young people most in need of help to find work, particularly in Communities First areas. Participants on the scheme are also shown to be trapped in low wages, earning only 67% of the average for their age group whilst on the scheme, and only 76% of the average for their age group after they finish.
The report is an embarrassment to the Welsh Labour Government, who have claimed the scheme is the best of its kind in the world, as their own report notes that success levels are only on a par with other job creation schemes.
Eluned Parrott AM, Welsh Liberal Democrat Shadow Economy Minister, said:
"The Welsh Labour Government's own report has finally lifted the veil on Jobs Growth Wales, showing just how ineffective their scheme really is. The fact that three quarters of the young people on the scheme would have found work without it shows that they've learned nothing from their past mistakes.
"By wasting precious money on people that don't need the support, they are failing the thousands of young people in Wales that desperately do. This scheme has done absolutely nothing to help the most disengaged and disadvantaged young people in Wales, and has actually entrenched low wage levels in our young workforce.
"Perhaps most damning of all is the confirmation in this report that this scheme was set up in a rush as a political gimmick, and not to deliver real results and support for the young people of Wales. This money needs to be reinvested immediately to target support to those young people most at risk of long-term unemployment, giving them the skills and opportunities that Jobs Growth Wales has failed to deliver for them."